|
I have a small overheating problem. Car is a 94' miata with
no modifications.
The needle goes up only to the 3/4 mark
Ambient Temperature around 35C(95F) In the city (slow traffic)
Only overheats after 15 minutes of running at normal temperature
and with A/C on. If you turn A/C off will lower temperature SLIGHTLY
On the Road: Over heats when you turn A/C on or when you go up
a hill (5000+ RPM) It returns to normal temperature if you turn
A/C off or you drive around 4000 RPM in 5th gear
Coolant level is OK
Coolant color and mixture is OK
Fans turn on OK and at the right time
Just got my A/C recharged
Just got new oil (Castrol GTX3 10-40)
My guesses:
1. Radiators are dirty outside (bugs and dirt) not letting enough
air flow to pass through
2. Fans turn too slow (broken motor or bearings ??)
3. A/C recently recharged thus getting hotter in A/C's condensator
than before
4. Oil changed recently to semi-synthetic
5. Design flaw in the miata (A/C's condensator in front of engine's
radiator) OK in cooler temps but not in spanish weather .
6. Water pump
Any suggestions ? (6/00)
|
| 5: Lots of people drive MX-5s in very high temperatures
without overheating. Water pump, blocked radiator, thermostat could
all be faulty. And so could the gauge! (6/00) |
|
I have experienced the same sort of thing in similar conditions
- (before I fitted my baffle shroud - see below) You may find
the temperature will fall significantly if you pop the headlamps
up (at speed anyway - won't help in the city)
I don't think you have any faults, but it is a bit worrying.
Two suggestions:
1) Is the baffle shroud in place? (Covering the gap in front
of the top of the radiator) Or have you even got one? If not,
I suggest you make one - I have, but I've not been able to test
it (due lack of suitable conditions) properly yet. But I am told
it can make a big difference, and I have not had any sign of gauge
rising with air con on, high speed up hill at over 30 deg C. with
it fitted. I need 40 deg ambient - must come to Spain (next month
maybe!).
Extra shrouding to make sure that all the air that comes through
the mouth goes through the radiator may be a good idea (and you
have got the gravel tray fitted haven't you?).
2) Get a 160deg (F) thermostat. The normal thermostat begins
to open at 80.5-83.5 deg C (177-182 F) and is fully open at 95
deg C (203 F). I think the car runs with the thermostat just open
(ie at about 85 deg C) in normal conditions (say below 28 C ambient,
no air con, modest speed up hills) but will go up to thermostat
well open (say 93 deg C) in conditions you describe - and I think
the gauge will read about 3/4 then. (But I know a lot of people
think the gauge reads the same over a big temperature range.)
But I suppose that if the thermostat is nearly fully open anyway,
a cooler one will make little or no difference. You can get a
160 one from various miata.net suppliers (including Roebuck Mazda)
(6/00)
|
| Mine ocassionally on long motorway runs on a warm day gets quite
warm, into the upper part of the gauge, but never all the way, should
I be thinking about one of these baffles? I have a home made grille
which I should imagine contributes: http://themx5.homepage.com/grille/
(6/00) |
| One of my original home made grills used a diamond pattern alumnium;
the car ran significantly hotter on the run to work, so I took it
off before real overheating occured while stuck in a 40 mile jam
on the M6. My gauge, with Duetto grill and no shroud, never gets
much more than halfway on the gauge. (6/00) |
|
Hmm - it looks nice and will certainly keep stray rocks and wildlife
out. But I also think it will break up the air flow substantially,
so reduce cooling, and that could well explain some overheating
on long fast runs on hot days.
I have a Moss grill, and have never experienced overheating in
the UK (even without the baffle shroud) Any grill is going to
reduce airflow to some extent - look at garden windbreak - the
holes are a lot more than the solid bits, yet it breaks up (modulates)
the wind so that your plants survive the winter (from observation
of gardening wife! :-) ) But I did experience overheating without
the shroud in S France - way hotter weather than it ever gets
in UK.
I think a baffle shroud (or a different grill!) might help.
See http://www.teammiata.com/proR-cov.htm
for a picture of the pukka thing - some cars have them as standard
- if yours hasn't you could make one from sheet ally (like mine)
or sheet plastic. Easy if you make a cardboard template first
- and they're easier to fit and remove if you make it in two parts
with a split in the middle - helps to get it past the bonnet catch
handle. You need spacers under the shroud where the bolts are
- they are in sort of recesses. You'll probably need longer M6
(10mm spanner) bolts too. (6/00)
|
| The color of the coolant doesn't mean anything. What's the mixture
you are using???? Normal coolant is a 50% water 50% coolant mixture.
Change that to 70% distilled (or demineralized!!) water and 30 %
pure coolant. You might even want to think about 80%-20%. If you're
seeing frost in the Winter don't forget to change coolant back to
normal. (6/00) |
|
As some of you may of noticed at Jurby last week my car overheated
on the track. I replaced the thermostat and it's been driving
OK since, however I had another track day at Kirkiston yesterday
and after 3 laps of really going for it the car overheated again.
You could let it cool for 10 minutes and the temp guage would
stay about halfway until the 3rd lap, then quickly rise to H.
I was up against Caterams & AC Cobras so I was really, really
going for it :)
In my first track day I did a few months ago the car was fine,
but three things have changed.
1) I replaced the Standard Air Filter with a Cone Filter. This
is quite close to the Manifold, so maybe it is sucking in hotter
air?
2) I advanced the timing to 14 degrees.
3) I fitted letters to the front grill to act as a registration
(much to the disgust of Old Bill).
I guess they could be restricting airflow. Picture of modification
at http://members.tripod.co.uk/stripy_miata/plate.htm
Does any of these factors explain why the car is more prone
to heating up, or is it a combination of all three? Can anybody
suggest a fix? On the day some guys suggested wiring the AC fan
to come on when the other fan did. Has anybody done this? Also,
one of the Cobra guys suggested an additive to the cooling system
to stop the water overheating. I can't remember the make. Lastly,
another guy suggested draining the system to get the crud out
and refilling with less antifreeze. Any advice would be gratefully
received (7/00)
|
| The water Additive could be RedLine Water Wetter, which break
surface tension and is meant to keep engine cooler. Reg no on grill
will be restricting air flow and even disturbing it so less effective
cooling to rad. (7/00) |
|
Probably talking about Redline water wetter - meant to stop overheating
a bit. Less antifreeze will also do this but you need to top up
in winter again. I'd guess it's your numbers on the grill as 14
deg timing shouldn't make much difference from what I've read.
Have you fitted a cover fover the top of the rad to make sure
all the air getting into the grill goes to the rad's fins??
Can't you fit a lower temp thremostat as well, although it won't
stop overheating - it will just take longer to get up to those
temps. (7/00)
|
|
Your 3 mods won't really make the car prone to heating, although
the third might well do. Though not much, I'd have thought.
How many miles has the car done ? It might be that the coolant
is so full of crap that its affecting the efficiency of the cooling
system. I'd firstly try flushing it out - best if you can is to
remove the rad and reverse flush it - that is put water in from
the top and let it come out of the bottom (i.e. opposite to what
it does in real life). You might also wish to get some flushing
additive - Holts do one called "Radflush" - guess you can get
it across the water there. The additive the guys were going on
about is called a "water wetter" - Redline make it. It basically
increases the boiling point of the coolant in your system. It
also works - I've some friends who use it in Caterham's, specifically
for track days.
Finally, how about removing your thermostat altogether ? I remember
on one of my dad's old Rovers, we resorted to this because the
car used to overheat in heavy traffic, despite flushing and then
REPLACING the rad on it. It worked a treat - there was coolant
constantly going around the engine, so it kept the temp down just
that extra bit. For the odd track day, that extra bit of circulation
might give you the edge ? To be honest, I'm not sure how much
of a job this would be on a '5 - although on my dad's old motor
it was 3 bolts, and there it was. (7/00)
|
| It's worth draining and running 25% anti-freeze. Also try and
flush your radiator while you're at it. Water wetter is worth trying
too if you can find it easily. Those letters could also be doing
it, particularly if you have air conditioning. (7/00) |
| Why do you need to remove it (the radiator to flush it- ed)?
(genuine question) (7/00) |
| I think that (flushing) might be the answer, the "water" is a
brown colour and foams like Fairly Liquid! Probably hasn't been
flushed since it was made 60,000 miles and 9 years ago. I reckon
I'll try that first. (7/00) |
|
Finally, how about removing your thermostat altogether?
Unfortunately (under 'everyday' driving) this kills fuel economy
because the engine takes longer to warm up so runs richer for
longer. (7/00)
|
| Fuel economy would be the least of your worries, with your thermostat
removed the engine would be unable to heat up properly so engine
wear would increase significantly as the engine oil will not heat
up properly. (7/00) |
|
I think that might be the answer, the "water" is a brown
colour and foams like Fairly Liquid! Probably hasn't been flushed
since it was made 60,000 miles and 9 years ago.
If that's the case I fear for your rad as it is probably well-clogged
with limescale... Definitely worth trying a chemical flush at
same time as replacing coolant. I used Holts two-part - time-consuming
but thorough. (7/00)
|
|
I tried all sorts with my
V8, what worked in the end for me was the big expensive rad
from dealer alternative, but
you shouldn't have to go that far. I found that quite large areas
of my original rad weren't working - cold air coming through,
so I guess these things are prone to clogging up. It's relatively
easy to pop the rad in and out (I became expert at it) (mind you
mine doesn't have the fans bolted to it) get it flushed out properly
- I tried to use bath taps (far from ideal & didn't work) & holts
radflush also did nothing. guess you need to use a fire hose or
something to back flush it effectively.
Good luck with it anyway, symptoms sound just like mine was.
The chemical mentioned was redline water wetter which sounds like
credible kit & I'll get some soon, mostly for corrosion protection
- theory it must be that whats blocking the waterways in the rad.
"breathe through " numberplate - I would think you'll get lots
more restriction from the mesh than the letters ignition advance
would be infinitesimal in its effect - if it does make the car
more efficient then there should be more of the energy going in
appearing as mechanical work therefore less as heat - I know well
dodgy theory...
Seen some other replies now so I'll add me 2p worth extra flaps
in bonnet catch area & gravel tray components - made no difference
to my setup - but I've left them in
holts radflush was utterly useless - maybe the 2part one someone
mentioned is a bit more viscious
antifreeze conc. made no discernable difference
I put in some bonza bonnet vents - made no difference
if you reverse flush the rad in situ you'll spray filth all over
the engine! plus getting a big hose to the bottom rad pipe also
sounds difficult. BTW the water wetter stuff doesn't alter the
BP or temp. of the coolant, but reduces actual engine temp. by
making better thermal contact coolant to metal - thermostat determines
coolant temperature (if everything else is working......) (7/00)
|
|
found that quite large areas of my original rad weren't
working - cold air coming through, so I guess these things are
prone to clogging up.
And therein lies the problem. All the extra kit (shrouds, louvres,
water wetter, etc) won't help if your radiator is basically not
working. So if that's the case, get it cleaned (properly) or get
an exchange one. Anything else is just bodging (eg removing thermostat)
and likely to damage your engine one way or another. Bob's case
is different - big engine, big fuel consumption, big heat - need
big radiator. The rest of you just need the standard radiator
working properly (forced induction engines might need a bigger
rad for hot track use) - with a bit of help from shrouds for extreme
use (sustained 100 mph in over 35 deg C)
If you maintain the cooling system properly, radiators don't
get clogged up. Always replace coolant every two years, and use
the proper amount of antifreeze - 30% minimum, 50% for preference.
If the coolant is rusty coloured when you buy the car, or goes
rusty looking very quickly, flush it and flush it and flush it
and change the coolant every three months until it's clean. Your
coolant should be blue-green (for most brands anyway). Anything
else, especially rust colour, calls for action! (7/00)
|
|
Removing thermostats needs a bit of care if you are racing the
engine - otherwise the flow pattern in the head gets screwed up
and you get differential cooling problems (I'm told!)
If you do it you need a thin blanking plate with a hole in it
that is not too big. This creates enough turbulence in the right
place but not as much flow resistance as the thermostat. (7/00)
|
| I read this while looking up USA sites about the radiator "You
would rid the block of more junk by using a commercial flush product,
but run the risk of starting leaks between the aluminum radiator
core and its' plastic tanks." Is this true, or Yank paranioa? :)
(7/00) |
|
Just to add my few pennies worth.... My ex-rad had done just
under 100K miles and at the last service the coolant was flushed
and replaced - closely following this, it generated a leak which
only leaked under cold conditions ( about 1 litre a week). It
wasn't until I got fed up with replacing coolant and removed the
radiator did I manage to find where it was coming from. The coolant
was coming from there the metal meets the plastic on the base
of the radiator - obviously the seal had gone. Replaced with a
roadster radiator and all is now fine.
Might be coincidence that the leak generated after a flush but
something to at least look for, especially in the older radiators.
Second hand units are relatively cheap! (7/00)
|
| I go with that (flushing can promote death of rad) .. generally
you are just buying time by the time you need to flush it .. they
normally fail at the crimps to the plastic tanks .. thermal stress/stress
fatigue from residual stress from the crimp .. no one is quite sure
which .. the other factors I have had is just coming out of winter
when the salt concentration seems to drop through a magical figure
.. especially with strong anti-freeze mixture (lost a radiator each
spring to these in 3 out 4 years once .. oh the joys of 8 year old
cars...) (7/00) |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |